Identifying Collections

Forums Mind and Psychology Identifying Collections

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    • #11179

      Hi Ashish

      Here, you say “a new foundation in which collections—rather than objects—are the most fundamental entities“.

      My question is does my perceiving a certain collection to be a certain object make it to be so? For eg., consider a slab of wood – I can see it as a chair and choose to sit on it, someone may see it as a table and use it to put things on it etc. So what is that piece of wood – a table or a chair or both?

      A similar conundrum appears in Mahabharata in the Krishna lifting the wheel incident. Some argue it was a weapon and some say it wasn’t. How is that conflict resolved?

    • #11181

      Please read this post in full: “The Sāñkhya claim is that the possibility of being used to cut vegetables, to tighten a screw, to hurt somebody, and infinite other use cases, are objectively present in the knife. Our desire only ‘selects’ one of these possibilities, and doesn’t ‘create’ them.”

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!

Identifying Collections

Time to read: <1 min